A Beginner’s Guide: Using Social Media to Build Donor Trust

Read time: 3-4 Minutes

We usually think of social media as just about posting updates. But, it’s one of the most powerful ways to build trust with your donors. (And when donors trust you, they’re more likely to give!)

The most effective nonprofits don’t just share what they do; they show how they’re credible, transparent, and making a real impact.

In this issue of Changemaker Mondays ☀️ ☕ 🌍, we’re diving into five powerful ways to use social media to build donor trust—so you can turn followers into long-term supporters.

​

1. Meet Donors Where They Are 🎯

Every nonprofit has a different target audience. I know, I know. It may seem like you should want to reach everybody, all the time, everywhere. But spreading yourself too thin across too many social media platforms can actually dilute your message and lose you some credibility.

Start by considering who your top target audience(s) are, and meet them on the platforms they hang out on. For example…

• LinkedIn → Great place to connect to corporate sponsors, business professionals, and grantmakers.
• Facebook → Ideal for engaging local communities and older donor bases.
• Instagram & TikTok → Great for younger audiences and visual storytelling.
• YouTube → A powerful tool for long-form storytelling and thought leadership.

​
2. Use Thought Leadership to Build Trust 🤝

People trust experts. When your nonprofit consistently shares insights and research on the issues and behind-the-scenes content, it positions you as a leader in your space – and someone donors can trust to make an impact with their dollars.
​
So, how do you do it? Try this:

• Share data-driven insights on your cause to educate your audience.
• Break down complex issues in simple, digestible ways.
• Offer solutions or perspectives that spark conversation…

​
3. Make Every Post Tell a Story 📖

People give because of people, not organizations. The best way to build trust is to show donors the real impact of their support through authentic human storytelling.

Try this:

• Share real stories, not just statistics. Numbers can feel abstract, but names and faces make giving personal. This is due to what’s called the “Identifiable Victim Effect,” which is a psychological phenomena in which people feel more emotional connection to the story of one person (or animal) rather than statistics about many people (or animals).
• Use first-person narratives from people your nonprofit has helped (where appropriate, and always with permission).
• Keep it compelling and end with a clear call to action.

​
4. Show Transparency & Real Impact 📊

Here’s something I learned throughout my nonprofit work and many interesting conversations: It’s hard for people to support something they don’t understand.

So our job is to help make it clear and bring folks along for the journey. 🙂

Donors want to know where their money is going. Transparency builds confidence that their gift is making a difference.

You can try:

• Showing behind-the-scenes updates to make donors feel like insiders and are a part of the mission. This really demystifies how it all works!
• Using visuals like photos, infographics, and short videos to break down financials or program impact.
• Reporting back on fundraising campaigns to show how donations were used and what’s next.

​
5. Have a Distinct Brand Voice 🎤

A clear, consistent brand voice builds trust making your nonprofit feel familiar and reliable. If your messaging is all over the place, it’s harder for donors to understand what your message really is, and trust it.
​
Think about how you can:

• Define your nonprofit’s “personality”: if your organization were a human, would it sound “warm and friendly,” “urgent and action-driven,” or “educational and inspiring?”
• Stay consistent in your tone across all platforms.
• Use emotion and authenticity to stand out.

​

Try It Yourself!

Test one of these trust-building strategies this week! Do you already use any of these approaches? Hit reply and tell me what’s working for your nonprofit—I’d love to hear from you! 😊
​

3 more ways I can help you

1. I have lots of free content for you! Check out my library of 250+ educational videos on nonprofits, social entrepreneurship, fundraising, and more on my YouTube channel. If you like what I’m trying to do, help me reach more people like you – who want to make an impact – by subscribing to the channel and sharing it with a changemaker friend! 😁
   ​
2. Need extra support to build or grow a nonprofit or social enterprise? Check out my Changemaker Accelerator membership. Learn more and join.
   ​
3. Need a speaker or training workshop for your social impact event? I’m currently booking 2025 speaking engagements — check out my speaking and workshop opportunities to learn how I can help you make your event inspiring and actionable!