9 Must-Have Skills to Lead
a Thriving Nonprofit

Read time: 4 Minutes

I’ll be the first to tell you, I had no real idea about what it was going to take to lead a successful nonprofit when I first started.

Oh sure, I thought I knew.

But like many, I had a glamorous view of nonprofit leadership:

  • Getting on the ground and directly helping people in need all the time!
  • Giving inspirational speeches!
  • Getting all the grants to cover all of our expenses and then some, because we were sooo awesome! 😆

Needless to say, I was missing a few key elements back then.

That’s why, in today’s issue of Changemaker Mondays ☀️ ☕ 🌍, we’re going to recap some of the other skills nonprofit founders and leaders need to help their organization succeed.

Changemaker Mondays is brought to you by:

Nonprofit Book Summaries for busy changemakers like us 😀

Sometimes I just don’t have time for reading the way I wish I did. Enter: Bitesized Books!

They’ve got over 50 book summaries (from experts on fundraising, management, and more) and you can learn so much about managing teams, raising money, and more from these gems. Digest the top lessons from each book (10x faster), and if you want, even connect with other social impact leaders (like me! 👋) in the membership chat.

Join me! It’s already super affordable, but you get a HUGE discount (40%) when you use this code at checkout: AMBER

Let’s jump in:

1. Strategic Planning and Long-Term Thinking

Every nonprofit or social impact organization needs a vision and a roadmap for achieving it. That’s what strategic planning is all about.

Social change doesn’t happen overnight, and a solid plan helps break down large goals into manageable steps. But it’s not just a best practice – having a strategic plan is directly tied to nonprofit success. According to the Journal of Management Studies, organizations with written plans grow 30% faster. And in another report featured on NonprofitPro noted that 86% of nonprofit respondents said having a strategic plan improved their ability to get funding!

Quick Tip: Haven’t got a strategic plan yet? Start by surveying your community to ask for their feedback on your mission and needs.

2. Board Governance

Your board of directors plays a crucial role in your organization’s governance. Effective board governance involves establishing clear processes for recruiting, training, and empowering board members.

Poor board governance is a big problem, leading to financial oversight issues, fundraising challenges, and delays in delivering programs.

Wondering if your Board is effective? I made this video checklist to figure that out. Let me know what you think!

Quick Tip: Good board governance starts with a strong Board Chair. Think ahead to consider who might be a good candidate for a mission-oriented, collaborative Chair with experience to lead the board and support your organization’s goals.

3. Human Resources & People Management

Did you know? Poor staff management can lead to high turnover, and losing staff can be an expensive proposition that impedes your ability to achieve your mission. According to the Society for Human Resource Management, it can cost up to 6-9 months of an employee’s salary 😨 to replace them.

Quick Tip: Treat salaries, professional development, and a positive work culture as investments (because they are!). Research and establish competitive salaries and training to retain talent as much as possible.

4. Volunteer Management

Volunteers are vital, but – just like staff – turnover can negatively impact your mission. The Stanford Social Innovation Review found that poor volunteer management leads to about one-third of volunteers not returning the following year.

Quick Tip: Start excellent volunteer management with setting expectations for volunteer roles. Create detailed volunteer job descriptions that match roles with your organization’s goals to underscore how the volunteer makes an impact for your cause.

5. Collaboration & Partnerships

Collaboration is essential in the interconnected world of nonprofits. Effective and properly supported partnerships can open doors to new resources, increase credibility, and expand your reach (and the data backs this up).

Quick Tip: Before you partner with another organization, clearly define roles and responsibilities with partners to avoid misunderstandings. A top reason partnerships don’t succeed is a lack of clarity around who does what!

6. Fundraising & Donor Stewardship

Fundraising is scary. I get it. But it’s one of the most important roles of a nonprofit leader. After all, you can’t achieve your organization’s goals without resources!

Many people assume fundraising is just about asking for money, but that’s probably the smallest part of it. It’s actually mostly about building and maintaining relationships. Relationships lead to more donors retained year over year – which is great, because improving your donor retention by just 10% can double the lifetime value of your donor database, according to Bloomerang’s Dr. Adrian Sargeant.

Quick Tip: Focus on storytelling and engagement to build relationships before making the ask. Share a story about someone impacted by your cause or impact data, at least quarterly!

7. Legal & Financial Management

Understanding the legal and financial aspects of running a nonprofit is crucial. Nonprofits must comply with strict regulations, and failing to do so can lead to penalties or even shutdowns. And if a compliance issues forces you to close your doors, well, you can’t help all those people you want to help.

Quick Tip: Educate yourself on compliance basics. Inventory what you don’t know, and seek experts in your community who can talk to you or offer training for your team.

8. Technology & Online Presence

You can’t get by these days without proper investment in technology and a solid website for your nonprofit. A well-designed website (and active social media, too) make your organization more accessible to supporters. Conversely, a poorly designed website turns donors and volunteers away.

Quick Tip: If tech isn’t your strong suit, consider tapping into university internship programs or recruiting skilled volunteers to help develop your online presence.

9. Marketing & Public Relations

If a nonprofit has a compelling mission, but nobody knows it exists, does it get the support it needs to help its community?

(It’s not really rhetorical question. The answer is No.)

McKinsey talks about how marketing budgets are usually the first to be cut in challenging times. But, as they say, that can be short-sighted. After all, it’s effective marketing that attracts donors, volunteers, and partners, sustaining your organization in the short AND long-term.

Quick Tip: If you haven’t already, clearly define your core messages and write them out in a Key Messages and Talking Points document including your mission, top goals, and facts about your cause. Share that document with your entire Board, staff, and core volunteers.

Final Thoughts

There you have it!

I’m curious – Which of these skills do you feel you’re excelling in? Which ones give you nightmares? Hit reply and let me know what you think. 🙂

Resource Roundup

💲

Funding Opportunities

  • Due September 12: Dominion Energy grants support nonprofits in states where the company does business and focuses on education, the environment, culture and the arts, civic and community development, and health and human services.
  • Due September 13: The Two for the Trails grant (ranging $500 to $50,000) supports nonprofit trail organizations, environmental protection organizations, and other nonprofit volunteer groups with outdoor protection and restoration projects.
  • ICYMI: Due September 15: Robert Lehman Foundation provides grants up to $50,000 to museums, arts organizations, educational institutions, and other nonprofits who promote the visual arts.

📅

Events & Programs

  • September 17 (12 PM ET | 9 AM PT): How to Find the Best Grants for Your Nonprofit’s Mission
    In this webinar and Q&A, we’ll tackle questions like:
    How do you discover and search for available grants?
    How do you identify which grants might fit your mission and needs?
    How do you assess which grants are worth your time to apply for?
    LEARN MORE AND REGISTER HERE

3 more ways I can help you

  1. I have soooo much free content for you! Check out my library of 200+ educational videos on nonprofits, social entrepreneurship, fundraising, and more on my YouTube channel. If you like what I’m trying to do, help me reach more people like you – who want to make an impact – by subscribing to the channel and sharing it with a changemaker friend! 😁
  2. Looking for a keynote speaker or workshop presenter on nonprofit management, social impact, and inspiring changemakers for your event? I’m booking 2025 speaking engagements now! Check out my Nonprofit, Corporate, and College speaking catalogues for topics here.
  3. Are you a social impact-minded brand? Promote your work to 6,400+ subscribers by sponsoring this newsletter. Partnerships power this content so we can equip more changemakers with the tools they need to change their communities.

Hey, Changemaker!

I’m Amber, writer of the Changemaker Mondays newsletter! I’m a nonprofit founder, speaker, and social entrepreneur on a mission to equip you with the tools you need to create positive change where ever you live — whether you’re starting a nonprofit or socially-conscious business, looking for a social impact job, or leading a volunteer project in your city. Don’t hesitate to connect (socials below), or reply to this email if you ever have any feedback on how we can make Changemaker Mondays the best newsletter for supporting changemakers in the world!

Changemaker Mondays newsletter is supported by its audience! When you purchase through links in this newsletter, we may earn an affiliate commission.